Hi Marine74,
Yes it is right to know why one has a problem since the two other pumps are working fine. Your curiosity is good.
Material standard in our company for effluent water service is 316SS construction with hard facing of wear rings (nitronic 50/60) for the protection from wear cause by abrasives.
Your problem is your loosing impeller. For a 18" and larger pump (yours is 20"

the standard is keyed impeller and not tapered sleeve fit type. Taper locked is only good for 17" below.
Now modifying or reverse engineering on pump may cause problem specially on balancing.
You must contact Allis Chalmers for them to replace your bowl assembly with a keyed impeller.
You may consider also putting hardfaces on your wear rings and bushings.
You can also put strainer.
Hope that helps.
